Business

Popular Pressure Ushers Recent Progressive Tilt

Study Cites Movements for Massive Shift in DC

The spate of reform initiatives undertaken by the Administration and both houses of Congress can be attributed directly to grassroots advocacy, according to a comprehensive study due out this month.

Protests organized by Witness Against Torture helped pave the way for the close of the Guantánamo facility.

Protests organized by Witness Against Torture helped pave the way for the close of the Guantánamo facility. (KC IVY/The New York Times)

“In education and health care, most notably, but also in housing, banking, and the environment, we have documented unprecedented responsiveness on the part of political leaders,” said Dr. Joyce Wellmon, director of the Plains Institute for Policy Analysis, a New York-based think tank. “Our data show a direct correlation between the level of activity of particular coalitions, on the one hand, and specific legislative action, on the other. It’s popular pressure that is responsible for the swiftness and scope of legislation emerging from the White House and Congress.”

The institute’s report shows a three-fold increase in the incidence of letters, phone calls, faxes, and email received by congressional offices, 88 percent of which were from people who identified themselves as new members of particular activist organizations. The report includes extensive interviews with House and Senate staff, who speak of “unimaginable change,” a “dramatic policy shift,” and “a new era of accountability” since the elections.

“Not since the Great Depression has the interaction between popular movements and public leaders been so robust,” said Jorge Lazaro, head of the U.S. Government Accountability Office. Lazaro cited, in particular, the Wagner Act, also known as the National Labor Relations Act of 1935, which recognized the right of workers to organize and bargain collectively with their employers.

“Roosevelt showed no interest in the Wagner Act until it became clear the unions were going to force it through regardless,” Mr. Lazaro noted. “At that point he jumped on it and helped push it into law.”

Mr. Lazaro also pointed to the Depression-era organizing of the Farmers’ Holiday Association, when farmers refused to sell or bid on crops, blockaded roads, and even once used a torpedo to halt a train carrying livestock into Iowa. Such direct actions helped push courts and legislatures to adopt measures that granted relief from debt caused by low crop prices.

“The similarities between the two periods are remarkable, and the lesson that emerges is simple: if you want change, keep our feet to the fire.”

Dr. Wellmon agrees. “The only reason the current President and Congress have been able to implement all these changes, was because of pressure from popular movements that made them have to.”

The Plains report, due out next month, cites the work of groups associated with United for Peace and Justice, an umbrella for anti-war groups, for galvanizing public support for ending the war, and for pushing the Administration to resist the oil lobby and other interest groups. It also cites the work of groups such as Healthcare-NOW, United Students Against Sweatshops, Housing Works, the A.C.L.U., and others for helping advance progressive causes such as universal health care, worker rights, civil liberties, and economic justice.

“There’s no question that in all areas, mass movements made the difference. Without them we wouldn’t be close to a national health program, a wind and solar bill, a plan to guarantee fair and equal funding for public education, or the banking oversight bill, expected to pass next month in both houses.”

“I never anticipated the rapid advances made in the past six months,” Dr. Wellmon said, “but the public has shown a fierce desire for change. It’s a virtuous cycle: with the breaking of market manacles, human and financial resources are becoming available to support even more real changes in all areas of American life.”

26 Comments so far ...

1. Chris

Thank you for this important article and nod to the countless of people that have collectively harnessed their energy, creativity and skills to advance justice. Looking forward to more articles like this, chris

Comment on November 12, 2008 05:09 pm

Woeat you fou this important and nod

Comment on November 13, 2008 04:06 am
3. carlos vigueras

New world is possible for all the people.We need to change US and build
a new economic order.THE UNITED STATES need a big change and the global society must have to work for a better life.
The solution is in our hands.All we need is to work together.

Comment on November 13, 2008 01:46 pm
4. carlos vigueras

Un mundo mejor es posible para toda la humanidad. Todo lo que nosotros necesitamos es construir un nuevo orden económico. Los EU necesitan un gran cambio y la sociedad global debe trabajar junta por una mejor vida.
La solución está en nuestras manos. Todo lo que necesitamos es trabajar juntos.

Comment on November 13, 2008 01:52 pm
5. Barista

Finally large groups of people can lobby Washington! Take that lobbyists!

Comment on November 13, 2008 03:28 pm
6. Samuel Schwarzman

THANKS, THANKS, THANKS

You’ve done a remarkable service to the country !!!!!!

Comment on November 13, 2008 04:20 pm
7. G Leary

Yeah! We get to give up more freedoms! Here is to the new bulsheviks. It was so good last time, it is bound to work out this time!

We just need that perfect god-like person to make all our lives work and the world will be a peaceful utopia of loving people….or reality will set in, the people will revolt, and we will finally regain our freedom, the one proven method to peace and prosperity.

Comment on November 13, 2008 05:29 pm
8. marc

The nonprofits are not able to lead us out of this mess, nor are the antiwar groups.

The key to mass organizing lies with the only national network of any significance, Obama’s network, and it all depends on how he decides to deploy it as a legislative tactic.

Comment on November 14, 2008 01:08 am
9. Philip Ganchev

Thank you for helping to start the movements that this article talks about! This is a tremendous idea excellently done! The Onion is just a bunch of pointless silliness, but NYTSE is inspiring, uniting and moving!

Comment on November 14, 2008 03:21 am
10. Lee

This edition reads like a Socialist/Leftist/Progressive/New School wish list. Priming New Yorkers and the rest of us for the ideas and policies to come.

Yes, the Bush administration screwed up much.

But that is not justification to nationalise most of the economy, bailout everyone, enact National Healthcare, and appease our enemies.

We have good laws and regulations in place on the books, now, today, November 13, 2008. All we needed to do was ENFORCE the laws. The cops were no where to be seen. So now this lapse will be justification for wealth redistribution.

Sorry, I am not playing. It’s my money, and you don’t get to have it.

Comment on November 14, 2008 03:27 am
11. Mabus

Oh, but lobbyists will be banned. Hello, people…wake up.

Comment on November 14, 2008 04:09 am
12. Karen

Why is there nothing in these wonderful and glorious pages about gay marriage????? I hoped to find an article titled “Texas becomes the last state to give our gay population equal rights to marry”. Where is this article? I love everything else but some people in my life feel like second class citizens now. I sent this to cheer them up and it only proved to them that they were not included in the progressive movement. Please, please tell me I’m missing something. I only found one bit of info of groups supporting gay issues but no articles.

Comment on November 14, 2008 08:05 pm
13. Angie

In the impending time of crisis the US will need control of their major industries as a co-ordinated effort.

The oil companies which operate in the country will need to restrict the sale of national supplies, unless you want to be chewing through Colorados’ expensive shale oil as a last resort…but these are still scarce in nature. The national oil reserve is temporary in nature, and designed as an aid in getting back to normal trade patterns.

In these crucial times the country needs to be out of the hands of petty, short-sighted and greedy institutions. Now the country has a backbone, and that is the country which we seek to preserve by taking hold of.

Besides, this country will never, ever-Ever!, nationalize much more than a few key resource and manufacturing lines for a really rather short-term. red-ink operation (the type of operation a government is good at running)–that would only be started-up (a huge, national effort), and then sold because the government needs the money!

I don’t see ANY long-term threat in considering these operations. The south will never be defeated! Our long-line of bad-assery has already resulted in one chuck norris….let’s not make it two, hm?

Comment on November 16, 2008 08:13 pm

JOIN THE IMPACT
It’s Big
It’s Beautiful
&
You’re gonna love it.

Comment on November 17, 2008 12:54 am
15. liam

Lee, you a fool! (In the best MR. T voice) Nationalise the economy under Obama? no dude, that’s what Bush did….$700 Billion woohoo! Let’s give that to our pals in Corporate America!

Comment on November 17, 2008 02:39 am
16. miasma

this site is so good it brings a tear to my eye

Comment on November 18, 2008 09:03 pm
17. Scott Free

With the vast menagerie of things that Americans want and/or need but don’t have because their ostensible government represents not them but the corporate culture in all it’s permutations, and in light of the things Americans really need and don’t have but don’t know it because their government has colluded in keeping them in the dark about them, it is high time for them to take to the streets, the only way Americans have ever gotten anything from their government, and dump this king president thing, and enact a parliamentary representational one.

Comment on November 25, 2008 08:01 pm
18. Me

Test alert(’Great Site’);

Comment on November 27, 2008 03:06 am
19. Me

Love It alert(’Great Site’);

Comment on November 27, 2008 03:07 am
20. Me

adfs

Comment on November 27, 2008 03:09 am
21. Me
22. Me

what

Comment on November 27, 2008 03:12 am
23. Me

Well, this would be the socialist’s dream. Popular support for massive taxes, massive bureaucracy… This would be the first time in history that people knowingly and consciously throw away their freedoms and opportunities for state enforced mediocrity.

All these changes would make Castro, Mao, Putin, Stalin and all those other freedom loving comrades glow with pride that the world-wide revolution finally achieved its goal: The Stalinization of America

Comment on January 25, 2009 10:37 pm
25. Krid

OK, that’s strange: the article is dated July 4, 2009, but the comments are from November of 2008. What’s up with that?
BY THE WAY, as long as I’m here, all you “Yes, sir” blind sheeple, you appreciate all that the Marxist president has done (Let’s see, how many campaign promises have been broken? 10? 20?) but you will NOT appreciate where it takes you. I wish I could be there to see your shocked faces when he finally betrays YOU, TOO.
This country was founded on freedom. If you sheeple want a country where you can be the progressive’s slaves, drooling and fawning, go start your own!

Comment on July 4, 2009 10:31 pm
26. joe

So, to be quite fair, very few people have actually seen this stuff. Why doesn’t anyone turn this into a 24 hour fake news network?

Comment on July 8, 2010 07:08 pm
(required)
(will not be published) (required)
(opitional)